November 23, 2009
Talent pool: Where does the talent come from?
MORE: Greatest State Debate Finals | Rank the states 1-50 | Top 100 HS football teams
Our quest to determine which state is best for high school football continues - mainly because the e-mails about our efforts continue to pour in.
First, there was the RivalsHigh Greatest State Debate, our own tournament creation.
Then, there were my personal rankings.
But still, the e-mails persist.
How can you not rate California higher? It produces the most D1 players, our readers write.
Our readers are right on that point.
But my continued analysis that the Golden State is a bit down remains accurate. Here's why: Much of California's success comes from its huge population base.
California produced the third-highest number of signees in 2009. But when you average the number of signees against the number of participants, California's success rate goes way down.
At just one signee for every 438 players, it doesn't even make the top 15 states for producing talent.
Is that you laughing Texas? I hope not. You're just two spots ahead of California. And both of you are below Hawaii, Nevada and Utah.
These rankings were created by dividing the number of D1 signees in the Rivals.com database into the number of participants in the sport, according to the National Federation of High School Sports participation survey.
Not buying it? Think these rankings must be flawed? Think again. Traditional high school strongholds Georgia, Louisiana, Ohio and Pennsylvania all fared well, ranking above California and Texas.
As did Florida.
Hate to break it to you California and Texas - but in these rankings, Florida is No. 1. The Sunshine State's number is amazing as it produced one D1 signee for every 127 participants.
As with our previous rankings, it is open to interpretation and debate. So send us an e-mail... or post on the board.
Talk about it in the highschool Message Boards
-- Brandon Risner contributed to this report
RIVALS.COM TEAM NEWS
Fletcher QB visits Mississippi State
Sandalwood WR commits to UCF
Houston Speed & Skill: Recruiting Notebook
Houston Speed & Skill: Sterling-Cole names leader
All Southern California High School Football Defense 2014/2015
Ranking the nation's top 25 schedules
No. 16 Miami Central has nation's top schedule
Rivals.com is your source for: College Football | Football Recruiting | College Basketball | Basketball Recruiting | College Baseball | High School | College Merchandise
Site-specific editorial/photos ©2012 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved. This website is an officially and independently operated source of news and information not affiliated with any school or team.
Statistical information ©2007 STATS LLC All Rights Reserved.